Al Giorgio's

Worst food I have ever ordered from Seamless! I am now eating cereal for dinner!! The spaghetti bolognese was soaked in greasy, buttery sauce. Not a tomato in sight!!! The meat was tasteless chucks of grey. The whole dish was doused in so much pepper, I knew it would be bad, before I even got the lid off!!! Right into the trash it went. $15 down the drain. There was no "saving" any part!! Just eat what u have in the cabinets, it will be much better!!

Written by Rea L. on 3/13/2013 | Member since 2010
Rea ordered from here within the last year

rude and never delivered

Written by Andrew K. on 11/27/2012 | Member since 2011
Andrew ordered from here within the last year

Was my favorite for years but the last 3 pizzas have been undercooked and short on sauce & flavor. I called twice to tell them i was disappointed but it's still the same. Too bad- used to be the best on the UES.

Written by Matthew S. on 10/13/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2008
Matthew ordered from here within the last year

GOOD JOKE. My pizza was delivered, 45 mins after it was supposed to be. The pizza was a ball and the end of the box, with a rude delivery man. I will absolutely never ever order from here. again. Thank you for a ball of cold cheese and bread.

Written by Trevor M. on 8/24/2012 | Member since 2009
Trevor ordered from here within the last year

crapola vodka penne

Written by Eric S. on 2/7/2012 | Member since 2011
Eric ordered from here over a year ago

ZERO STARS this is the worst customer service of any establishment I've ever dealt with. I placed an order 5 HOURS AGO and IT still has not been delivered. I call 3 TIMES asking for an ETA, all 3 times the girl on the phone told me it would be here in 20 minutes, but I'm still waiting. She showed 0 sympathy or urgency towards a customer that already paid via credit card. Its not even a large order either its a personal pie. I just came back from a deli to eat my dinner, I would like to have my money refunded but I seriously doubt that's going to happen. Which means Al Giorgio's Pizza basically stole my money and gave me the run around all day long. DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE

Written by richard r. on 1/3/2012 | Member since 2011
richard ordered from here over a year ago

Wow - nothing edible in the order. The app was burnt. The main was off. I am writing this 7 minutes after the food was delivered - and I have to order something else for somewhere else because I couldn't eat any of it.

Written by Peter S. on 8/4/2011 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2010
Peter ordered from here over a year ago

I ordered a Sicilian Pizza from Al Giorgios, thinking that the thick delicious breadiness of it would do nicely to soak up the previous night's boozing. Well, turns out they don't deliver the Sicialian Pizza (why the hell is it on the menu then!). So they called me from an unlisted number and left a voicemail, informing me of that and saying that they would just send a regular cheese pizza. Thirty minutes later (really, how long does it take to make a pizza? And the delivery time is the distance between 2nd and 1st avenues), I get my pizza. In short, it sucked. They were going for the old school look with dollops of tomato sauce instead of a bread, sauce, cheese layers. And the sauce was alright. But the bread was chewy and non-descript flavor wise, and in my opinion under-cooked. The whole experience was a waste of time, money and precious pizza calories.

Written by Justin H. on 3/7/2011 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
Justin ordered from here over a year ago

I ordered the Eggplant Parmesan. It was not breaded, small, and didnt come with pasta. Not a meal. I will never order this again.

Written by Julie S. on 2/21/2011 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2011
Julie ordered from here over a year ago

almost an hour waiting. hope it's worth it. Update. Pizza was almost cold, and the box was shaken around so much, it looked like half a pie (the other half had gotten mushed/pushed on top). Spinach Salad was forgettable. I won't be ordering from here again. I don't think they're at 91st & 2nd either. That should be checked out.

Written by ERIN F. on 10/12/2010 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2009
ERIN ordered from here over a year ago

I JUST GOT MY ORDERED DELIVERED. IT CAME FAST AND HOT. I ORDERED THE 12' GIORGIO'S FAVORITE. AND NOW IT'S MY FAVORITE TOO. THE SPINACH WAS DELICIOUS AND THE VEGETABLES WERE SO FRESH. AL GIORGIOS IS MY NEW FAVORITE PIZZA ON THE UPPER EAST SIDE!!!!!

Written by michelle v. on 9/27/2010 | Member since 2010
michelle ordered from here over a year ago

Totally disorganized delivery method. Really slow.

Written by Ben F. on 9/21/2010 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2010
Ben ordered from here over a year ago

Amazing!! I truly enjoyed the pizza, crispy thin crust with a prefect amount of sauce. Fast delivery too! I highly recommend this place to all those who love pizza.

Written by Gigi B. on 9/3/2010 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
Gigi ordered from here over a year ago

Terrible, thin crust. Food tasted like cafeteria lunch. They promised me a margherita pizza for free with an order of a 16", and so I expected a basil mozzarella pizza - all I got was yet another poorly made bland cheese pizza with rubbery crust - and no basil!! Horrible pizza - will never order from here again!!!!!!

Written by Chris H. on 8/26/2010 | Member since 2009
Chris ordered from here over a year ago

Tasty veggie pizzas.

Written by Mark S. on 8/18/2010 | 14 other reviews | Member since 2008
Mark ordered from here within the last week