Bella Vita Pizzeria (58th)

A disgrace. Pizza arrived ice cold and soggy. Bella Vita did not even bother to heat up an obviously old pizza before delivering it. Avoid at all cost.

Written by Jack C. on 5/3/2010 | Member since 2009
Jack ordered from here over a year ago

The pizza is extremely good. I do prefer it a little crispier, but still a really good pie with great flavor. Not many really tasty pizza sauces in the area, but Bella Vita definitely is one of the few. No delivery problems for us. The pepperoni calzone is a hidden gem - my girlfriend and I both love them. We didn't really care for the chicken parmesan or the penne vodka (I'd give them 3 stars), but we'll certainly order pizza and calzones from here again.

Written by Eric W. on 8/3/2009 | 29 other reviews | Member since 2008
Eric ordered from here over a year ago

Good chicken parm, fast delivery

Written by jon l. on 2/23/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2012
jon ordered from here within the last month

Such good pizza. Delivered it at work and now all my co-workers ask about it. I got mushroom and sun-dried tomato (then we later ordered another broccoli and onion)

Written by Khushbu V. on 2/6/2012 | Member since 2010
Khushbu ordered from here within the last year

Delivery was late and the dough in the Sicilian Pizza Pie was uncooked in the middle. Not appetizing.

Written by Joel P. on 1/3/2012 | Member since 2007
Joel ordered from here over a year ago

the pizza is BANANAS, the dishes are fantastic ,and the owner is the chillest guy in the world!! def order here it is worth every penny..ps always get the garlic nots they will blow your mind

Written by sophia h. on 12/22/2011 | 16 other reviews | Member since 2010
sophia ordered from here over a year ago

Worst service ever. We ordered a pizza after reading the great reviews. First of all, it took an hour to arrive. And when it came, it was cold -- not warm -- but cold, and the cheese was hard. So we called back, and they said they would send another pizza, which was very nice. Don't get me wrong. But it took 1 hour and 15 minutes for them to send the second pizza. If they wanted to keep customers happy, they would've sent the second pizza out as soon as possible. Won't be ordering from here ever again.

Written by rachel m. on 12/15/2011 | Member since 2011
rachel ordered from here over a year ago

Food is ok but horrible delivery service. Ordered food, was told 25-40 minute wait. Called 1.5 hrs later and they claim they hadn't even started making the food and then hung up the phone on me. This was just a random normal night, not any reason for them to be particularly busy (i.e., superbowl, etc.).

Written by Anand M. on 11/25/2011 | Member since 2007
Anand ordered from here over a year ago

If I could give this zero stars I would. Tried ordering from here twice, both times the food never showed up. When I called I was told the delivery guy was out and should be back shortly... they never called to say that they couldn't get a delivery out. A complete disaster, I guess fool me once shame you , fool me..... , well you ain't gonna fool me again.

Written by rick O. on 9/26/2011 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2009
rick ordered from here over a year ago

I ordered a large pie with broccoli and onion. I live 2 blocks away from this place, but it took exactly 1 hour to deliver. The pizza was pretty weak -- soggy, with raw red onions.

Written by Benjamin S. on 8/22/2011 | Member since 2010
Benjamin ordered from here over a year ago

I used to order pizza from here often, but its gone downhill. Their pizza crust used to be crunchy, but over the last few months, its been soo soggy and wet in the middle. And it seems like they're skimping on the toppings and cheese. They always took a long time to deliver, but it used to be worth it.

Written by Ellen P. on 8/2/2011 | Member since 2010
Ellen ordered from here over a year ago

I ordered the white pizza-brick oven. Fast delivery, good tasting, quality ingredients. Definitely recommend!

Written by Kristin B. on 4/7/2011 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2011
Kristin ordered from here over a year ago

The pizza was okay. The meat toppings (sausage and pepperoni) were not particularly flavorful and there was not very much sauce or cheese on either the meat pizza or the plain pizza. The family sized arugula salad came with dressing mixed in (had ordered on the side) and was arugula, a few sundried tomatoes and a bit of parmesean. Not a good value.

Written by Joe P. on 4/5/2011 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2007
Joe ordered from here over a year ago

The pizza was just okay, but the salad? AMAZING. So good. I mean, fresh and that dressing is out of control delicious. I like putting a lot of stuff in my salads because normally the lettuce is boring filler but I literally clean my plate every time we order this extremely simple salad and a massive portion. They also give you complimentary garlic knots which are very yummy. This is my go-to lunch. Also, seamless will probably remove this part of my comment, but if you order from their website you can get 20% off. Just wanted to let you know.

Written by Kirby M. on 12/27/2010 | Member since 2010
Kirby ordered from here over a year ago

looked like it was dropped. never order from here

Written by Ilya G. on 10/18/2010 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2010
Ilya ordered from here over a year ago