Big Nick's Burger Joint & Pizza Joint (Bdwy)

Great pizza! Lightning fast delivery. Good prices. I order from from Big Nick's a lot.

Written by Alan E. on 5/21/2013 | Member since 2013
Alan ordered from here within the last week

Big Nick's pizza is the best in the Upper West Side. For a traditional NY slice, I don't bother ordering from any place else.

Written by Beverly G. on 5/19/2013 | Member since 2010
Beverly ordered from here within the last year

Horrible! It took them more then an hour and a half to deliver!! I called after an hour and they told me it hadn't left yet, with no apologies or anything. When I got it it was cold, fries were soggy and the burger was in a crappy pita bread instead of a burger bun... not ordering from there again!

Written by karin S. on 5/19/2013 | Member since 2012
karin ordered from here within the last week

They are HORRIBLE. I ordered a turkey burger with onion rings, a big nick soda, and a big nick's melt with a black and white milkshake. First, they deliver the burger on a freaking hot dog bun and my milkshake was missing and there were no onions rings. I called back three times and the customer service over the phone was horrid. The man had an attitude and gave the excuse that it was too busy. It does not take over 2 hours to redeliver a milkshake and onions rings. Disrespectful. And they acted as if I were bothering them about an order they messed up! They don't even deserve one star.

Written by Elizabeth R. on 4/29/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2012
Elizabeth ordered from here within the last month

big nicks is a good late night delivery spot food will come quickly late at night the delivery man will call and complain about coming inside your building very very lame

Written by morgan g. on 4/9/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2012
morgan ordered from here within the last year

It took them over an hour to deliver my order and I had to call several times. First time they told me my order had already been delivered (I disputed that), second time they told me the guy was just a few blocks away, 10 minutes later I hadn't received the order. I called twice again before the burger arrived. Obviously, it was cold. Not ordering there again.

Written by Bruno R. on 4/7/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2011
Bruno ordered from here within the last year

Very late delivery, rude guy on the phone. Too bad their burgers are good. Customer service sucks. There are plenty of other good burger places around, don't spend your money on a business that doesn't give a damn about their patrons.

Written by Stan R. on 4/5/2013 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2011
Stan ordered from here within the last year

No more whole wheat pizza? This preggo is bummed out.

Written by Chrissy R. on 4/2/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2009
Chrissy ordered from here within the last week

This is our go to burger place. Get the Sumo burger deluxe every time. The best!

Written by heather g. on 3/28/2013 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2012
heather ordered from here within the last month

Just great - fast delivery. Pizza was a bit salty but crust made up for it -- tasted like an authentic NYC slice. Spinach pie great option for vegetarian. Waffle fries very tasty. We even got BIG NICK's on THANKSGIVING so for us, they are one of our favorite spots in the 'hood.

Written by GEETA C. on 3/8/2013 | 7 other reviews | Member since 2010
GEETA ordered from here within the last year

"A jack of all trades, but a master of none." Decent breakfast. Decent burgers. I wouldn't venture too far from that though. Pizza is terrible, although for the Upper West Side, it is probably above average. This is the quintessential UWS take out: quick delivery, mediocre, overpriced food, and an obnoxiously extensive menu. Great for 4 AM post-bar munches. In other words, their food tastes much better when you're intoxicated. 24 hour delivery is definitely a bonus though. I really wish there were better options around here, but alas, there are not. It's either pay $5,000 for a fancy (albeit delicious) meal from Sarabeth's, or settle for Big Nick's. Either your wallet will hurt, or your stomach will. Welcome to the Upper West Side.

Written by Alex S. on 2/26/2013 | Member since 2012
Alex ordered from here within the last year

Just ok, nothing special. Garlic bread was good and had a lot of flavor. The meatballs were small and the sauce had too much acid / not enough flavor. It tasted like it was out of a can. Friends have raved about things like the burgers to me, so I think if I am going to order from here again that will be the way I go.

Written by Polly W. on 2/15/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2012
Polly ordered from here within the last year

I like this place because its so reliable, the menu is extensive, and prices are reasonable. The food is what you would expect from your typical neighborhood joint. Snowed in? Call Nicks. Sick in bed? Call Nicks!

Written by Lauren T. on 2/15/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2012
Lauren ordered from here within the last year

This place is great! I ordered the Bistro Burger - the burger was great and the waffle fries are awesome! Delivered on time and the guy was nice. Also love the extras - a pickle came with my burger, and a small piece of baklava came with my order :) Will definitely be ordering again.

Written by Jenny G. on 2/5/2013 | Member since 2013
Jenny ordered from here within the last year

Best Burgers in town! Their delivery guys are very friendly. I have tried many burgers in NY and these guys really know what they are doing! A++++

Written by Kevin C. on 1/31/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2010
Kevin ordered from here within the last month