Bleecker Street Pizza

DO NOT ORDER CHICKEN. Their pizza is good, but their chicken is of awful quality and is NEVER, EVER cooked properly. I have tried at least 6 times to get decent chicken from this place. I've ordered the chicken pizza, the chicken parm hero, and the chicken parm dinner. The chicken is always terrible. Always. Do not order the chicken. The meatballs are a little better, but I would stay away from those as well. Seriously, stay away from the chicken. If you're still reading this review, I can tell you're a bro and I'll let you in on a little secret: DON'T ORDER ANY CHICKEN FROM BLEECKER STREET PIZZA

Written by Richard N. on 11/18/2012 | 7 other reviews | Member since 2010
Richard ordered from here within the last month

I love the pizza at Bleecker Street Pizza, but I recommend going in to get it. I've ordered delivery twice and both times got something different than I ordered.

Written by Jeremy S. on 8/15/2012 | 16 other reviews | Member since 2010
Jeremy ordered from here within the last year

I am the new office manager (been here 3 months) for a company withh about 50 employees. In this time I have been credited with many positive accomplishments. The one thing that got me the most recognition was when I was asked to order food for an all hands meeting. I Ordered An asssortment of pies, heros etc. from Bleecker Street Pizza. My boss and the entire office couldn't stop raving about the pizza, the sauce, the cheese, the heros, even the salad. I have to say that the Nonna Maria pie (that's their version of fresh mozz pie) was probably the best pizza I have ever eaten. While the food was astonishingly good it still annoys Ordering from Bleecker Sreet Pizza seems to have gotten me more credit than any of my many contributions to the company.

Written by anthony t. on 11/11/2011 | Member since 2011
anthony ordered from here over a year ago

Bleecker Street Pizza has a well-deserved rep for having awesome pizza ! Their best pizza is the Nonna Maria - there is almost always a few knowledgable people hanging around their counter waiting patiently and hungrily for the next fresh Nona Maria to come out of the oven. Every time we take friends and / or family here for their first time they immediatey know why we love living here. If you give this place a try it won't be long before you will be dran back to Bleecker Street Pizza again !

Written by eric b. on 8/8/2011 | Member since 2011
eric ordered from here over a year ago

I am a (self proclaimed) pizza connoisseur and a real professional chef. Bleecker Street Pizza has become my favorite place to eat. I don't heap praise on a food establishment easily but the pizza here is nothing short of amazing! The crust is thin, crisp and perfect. The sauce is old world and to die for. This pizza shop is using authentic Parmigiano-Reggiano on thier pizza. Any time I want to show off N.Y. pizza to my out of town family or this is where I order from. TIP: It's all great but my favorite is the Nona Maria fresh mozz pie. PIZZA PIZZA PIZZA

Written by abbey p. on 6/29/2011 | Member since 2011
abbey ordered from here over a year ago

The office I work in orders from Bleecker Street Pizza every week and it's a highlight of the workweek for us ! The Nona Maria pie , which has home-made marinara sauce and fresh basil, is my personal favorite. The guys are most tempted by the marinated grilled chicken and the pepperoni pizzas. The trays of fresh house salad make lunch healthy. My boss is in love with the plain pie - he claims it's magical how they make it so good. Visitors to our office on pizza day always ask if we can order the same NEXT time they visit. As our office's event planner , I know what we order from Bleecker Street Pizza will be a monster hit!

Written by ellen M. on 5/12/2011 | Member since 2011
ellen ordered from here over a year ago

Once again, they sent the wrong food. The girl laughed and her biggest concern was whether she could recoup the meatball sub (I ordered chicken parm). Third time I have order blue cheese with salad and received Italian dressing. She said they dont have blue cheese. I said take it off the menu then. She checked. "Oh, maybe we do have blue cheese." I am sorry but don't reward bad behavior by supporting Bleecker Street Pizza.

Written by Robert L. on 3/1/2010 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2009
Robert ordered from here over a year ago

I am back living in the West Village (thank god) and friends kept telling me to skip Joe's and try Bleecker Street Pizza. It took a few months but I have to admit they were right. My new favorite pizza shop is definately Bleecker Street and my favorite slice is the fresh mozz, they call it the Nonna Maria,whatever. Best slice I have ever had,period.

Written by bobby p. on 1/19/2010 | Member since 2010
bobby ordered from here over a year ago

Ive tried most pizza places below 23rd street and Bleecker Street Pizza is definetely my favorite. Their signature pie , Nonna Maria is positively out of this world. All of the pizza types there are excellent or better. The dinners and the salads are top quality & plenty of food.

Written by thomas l. on 10/29/2009 | Member since 2009
thomas ordered from here over a year ago

The pizza was pretty greasy. Came on time. Wings had no sauce on them. Very expensive for what we got. Next time I'll order dominos.

Written by Joseph S. on 5/12/2013 | Member since 2012
Joseph ordered from here within the last month

This place is a disaster. It's guaranteed, nearly every time, if you order something that's not a pizza -- so a drink, or a sandwich, or anything else -- they'll not deliver the proper item. In addition, I have ordered pizzas from them in the past -- a Grandmas to be specific -- and they delivered a regular pizza 45 minutes later. I called them, and they said "We just didn't have enough time for Grandma's today, so we sent this." They never deduct the difference in price on the bill of what they deliver versus what you order. If their pizza -- when they actually make them -- didn't taste as good as it does, I would NEVER order from these clowns.

Written by Scott K. on 3/31/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2007
Scott ordered from here within the last month

Not even close to the "best pizza in the city". Have gotten sick twice from eating here. Rude staff. I'd give zero stars if I could

Written by Greg K. on 3/31/2013 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2011
Greg ordered from here over a year ago

Best pizza in the city.

Written by Adam G. on 2/13/2013 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2005
Adam ordered from here within the last week

food good delivery terrible 1 hour 20 minutes for pizza really!!

Written by brian h. on 1/8/2013 | Member since 2010
brian ordered from here over a year ago

Order came quickly and the Grandma pizza was delicious! The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because I like my pizza with a bit of a thinner crust - but overall it was really great!

Written by Ilana B. on 11/27/2012 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2012
Ilana ordered from here within the last month