Fat Sal's Pizza (14th)

Service was terrible. Food didn't arrive for an hour and a half after expected. And even when I called the restaurant to ask about the delay, I was met with a horrifically rude response. I will never order them again.

Written by Thomas G. on 2/9/2013 | Member since 2008
Thomas ordered from here within the last year

Worst service ever. I ended up canceling delivery after an hour and a half of waiting... Will never order again.

Written by David S. on 10/8/2012 | Member since 2011
David ordered from here within the last year

I can't rate the food because it never arrived. After 80 minutes we went ahead and cancelled. They were jus super busy. The owner was extremely nice about the whole thing though!

Written by Christina S. on 10/1/2012 | Member since 2007
Christina ordered from here within the last year

Two times now, I have placed an order for 5+ pizza's and sode for a lunch event and the pizza never shows up. Upon calling Fat Sal's they claim that the order never came through, even though, I received confirmation from Seamless. Unreliable and non-accommodating to say the least.

Written by Liz V. on 9/29/2012 | Member since 2011
Liz ordered from here within the last year

The food isn't even here yet and already 35 minutes late...they said 15-30....

Written by Amy P. on 9/28/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2010
Amy ordered from here within the last year

Food is good, but delivery inconsistent. The amount of time shown when I ordered was 15-30 minutes, but I ordered over 1 hr and 45 mins ago and I am still waiting for my food!

Written by Alison N. on 8/17/2012 | Member since 2009
Alison ordered from here within the last year

My go to greasy pizzeria- the food definitely hits the spot if that's what you're looking for. Usually a pretty quick delivery, too, and I live towards the outskirts of the delivery zone. I must admit, however, that for every bunch of good orders, there is the occasional disappointing meal with lousy food that took forever to come. Well priced, though, and certainly worth playing the odds at least once.

Written by Whitney P. on 7/6/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2009
Whitney ordered from here within the last year

Took an hour, including a period when the delivery man was at the wrong address and called me, insisting that he was in the right location. Yeah, ok man. To top it off, didn't bring my drinks. The pizza isn't good enough to deal with that. I will never order from here again.

Written by Edward B. on 6/13/2012 | Member since 2008
Edward ordered from here within the last year

I thought the eggplant parm. was very good, but I like to try different restaurants, so I ordered an eggplant parm. sub from another restaurant. Big mistake! The sub from Fat Sal's blew the sub from the other restaurant out of the water! The Fat Sal's sub had a TON of eggplant, the sauce was good, and the bread tasted fresh. Fast delivery too! Well done Fat Sal's. 5 stars hands down.

Written by Christina H. on 4/7/2012 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2009
Christina ordered from here within the last year

decent enough, esp late night

Written by Gary R. on 1/9/2012 | 19 other reviews | Member since 2006
Gary ordered from here over a year ago

Took 55 minutes for delivery despite posted 15-30 minute delivery time and it was a weekend afternoon. Soup, sandwich and garlic knots were all disgusting.

Written by Thomas W. on 12/19/2011 | Member since 2006
Thomas ordered from here over a year ago

Super fast, knock your socks off Italian food. Their meat sauce and their olive oil /garlic w broccoli and chicken is like crack. The pizza is alright too.

Written by dominique w. on 10/20/2011 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2011
dominique ordered from here over a year ago

Pizza is great, the fresh mozzarella slice is as good as I've had in NYC. The rest of the menu is very mediocre, but they deliver fast so if you're in a hurry, this is your best bet!

Written by Jana Z. on 10/3/2011 | 14 other reviews | Member since 2011
Jana ordered from here within the last year

food was overcooked/dry/tasteless nothing special and definitely not worth ordering again

Written by Lawrence K. on 8/15/2011 | 16 other reviews | Member since 2008
Lawrence ordered from here over a year ago

Hells yea! This is what I call a pizza. I ordered two slices not knowing the slices are HUMONGOUS. Great tasting pizza. Going to my faves.

Written by Tero P. on 8/10/2011 | 9 other reviews | Member since 2011
Tero ordered from here within the last year