Justinos Pizzeria (Murray Hill)

We've ordered from Justino's many times and we have liked the food repeatedly. I like the L&B style pizza, and the regular pizza, eggplant parm and chicken parm heros are very good. Portions are generous. We usually have the same delivery guy and the food arrives hot. This week we had a really bad experience - we ordered a pizza and it took 1 hour and 10 minutes to be delivered after the email estimated 30-45 min. Okay, maybe they are busy. I never saw the delivery guy before - he must be new. He was on his cell phone the whole time. He must not have been paying attention to the pizza and turned it on its side because it was a mess when I opened the box, and even worse, it was ice cold. I don't know what this delivery guy was doing taking so long, throwing the pizza around and letting it get so cold. I called and they did the right thing by sending a new pizza, which was tasty and warm (not hot) when it arrived (it still took longer than it should have), and the delivery guy was still on his cell phone the whole time. I chalk it up to a new delivery guy that doesn't know what he is doing and a bad night. Hopefully he learns to get off his phone and deliver the pizza in better shape. I have always gotten the food hot and in good condition with the old delivery guy so will definitely give them another chance next week. I hope it was a just a bad night as the food is good and it is my go to pizza and hero place in the neighborhood.

Written by Peter F. on 5/16/2013 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2006
Peter ordered from here within the last month

They just put up $0.99 cent pizza signs, but the website still lists $2.50. I think their pizza has slipped a bit - the last 2 slices that I got were pretty tasteless. I would pay 99 cents for it...but not $2.50.

Written by Chung N. on 5/11/2013 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2011
Chung ordered from here within the last year

They changed owners in the last couple months and the food has stayed mostly pretty good, but they no longer carry coke, and Pepsi is obviously a horrible disgusting drink.

Written by Jeff C. on 3/22/2013 | 12 other reviews | Member since 2010
Jeff ordered from here within the last year

Good food. But they get the order wrong about 50% of the time which is frustrating.

Written by Julie S. on 2/14/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2006
Julie ordered from here within the last year

The eggplant parm dinner arrived an hour and 20 min after I ordered (which was only after I called th restaurant). The food was bland and the pasta overcooked. I wont order here again.

Written by Linda N. on 12/23/2012 | Member since 2009
Linda ordered from here within the last year

No one ever confirmed my order and when I called they said it "wasn't there problem".

Written by Joseph L. on 11/13/2012 | Member since 2008
Joseph ordered from here within the last year

Always forgets to include tomato sauce with calzones, even when I write it multiple times under special instructions. I called and complained, they promised to send it then didn't. I am DONE with Justinos.

Written by sam s. on 11/9/2012 | 7 other reviews | Member since 2006
sam ordered from here within the last year

Chicken Marsala Sub is AMAZING :)

Written by wendi m. on 10/26/2012 | Member since 2012
wendi ordered from here within the last year

Used to be pretty good. Now they never get orders right about the simplest things and their pizza is sloppy. How does two bottles of coke mean 2 diet cokes? And if I ask for a well done crust, is it so hard to leave in the oven for an extra 5 minutes? Instead its delivered with cheese and toppings barely hot. I'm done with these guys - way too many options in murray hill.

Written by Andrew H. on 7/29/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2010
Andrew ordered from here within the last year

ever been to LMB in Bensonhurst ? its pretty much the best pizza on the planet. they have an "LMB style" pizza here - sicilian with the sauce on top of the cheese. its not LMB but its the closest i can get in manhattan, it was pretty good. worth its existence just for making this style pizza.

Written by Ryan V. on 4/14/2012 | 13 other reviews | Member since 2009
Ryan ordered from here within the last year

The pizza sold actually in the resturant is good. But the delivered pizza is ok at best. Calzone came soggy and pizza was also

Written by Andrea L. on 3/31/2012 | Member since 2009
Andrea ordered from here within the last month

this place is amazing

Written by Eric N. on 3/12/2012 | Member since 2010
Eric ordered from here within the last year

Terrible Pizza. Soggy peppers & onions. Too much sauce, so that the toppings and cheese were falling off. Wings were OK, i've had worse... but that is not an endorsement.

Written by Adam M. on 2/21/2012 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2010
Adam ordered from here over a year ago

we ordered the simple cheese pizza, half with onions and peppers. pizza was not hot, onions and peppers were cut in big chunks. dough lacked flavor/salt and it was soft/moist, and tomato sauce was not tasty either. we were expecting better for a new pizza place.

Written by Juan B. on 2/21/2012 | Member since 2008
Juan ordered from here over a year ago