Pick A Bagel (3rd Ave)

I love this place. Comes on time, good quality and clean bagels. Their chicken noodle soup is pretty good and whenever I ask for extra anything their very accommodating. Perfect for a quick bagel craving

Written by Devika M. on 5/12/2013 | 7 other reviews | Member since 2011
Devika ordered from here within the last week

Not worth ordering anything from this store! The bialy and black and white cookie that was delivered was stale and the bagel was just ok. They would not take the stale items back and return my money. Poor business decisions and customer service, I will never order from here again!

Written by KellyAnne . on 5/4/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
KellyAnne ordered from here within the last month

Asked for a chopped salad and they didn't chop it, which is annoying. The turkey in the salad tasted like fish and was extremely low quality. Bagel was great. Be careful with the salads.

Written by Elizabeth M. on 4/19/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2011
Elizabeth ordered from here within the last year

Loved the bagels I got. They were really fluffy and perfectly toasted AND they have specialty whole wheat bagels, which is awesome. One of the best bagels I've had in NYC!

Written by Kelly M. on 8/15/2012 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2008
Kelly ordered from here within the last year

loved their bagels. they lasted a while, they were doughy, and they were huge

Written by Lindsay W. on 7/9/2012 | 19 other reviews | Member since 2010
Lindsay ordered from here within the last year

FAST DELIVERY- much better than the slow and incorrect gramercy bagels. order from here, theyre very good at seamless orders

Written by chris p. on 1/16/2012 | 15 other reviews | Member since 2009
chris ordered from here within the last year

Good delivery-great bagels and sandwiches. Bagels have a ton of cream cheese, but still good.

Written by Allyson R. on 4/6/2011 | 14 other reviews | Member since 2010
Allyson ordered from here over a year ago

Normally their bagels are pretty good. I always ask for the fresh bagels.

Written by Pedro E. on 3/3/2011 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
Pedro ordered from here over a year ago

actually a zero - zero stars... the food is eh, nothing at all to brag about i have had it before. to order online the minimum is far overpriced and when i designed my own bagel I was called by the store and told by the owner "we dont do that, i have 500 customers i cant make everyones specific sandwich request, we cant make what you want." what i wanted, was for my bagel to be open faced- all they had to do was not put the two halves together... just absurd i wouldn't spend my money here ever again :(

Written by kari p. on 12/4/2010 | Member since 2009
kari ordered from here within the last year

Not as good as Ess-a-Bagel, but definitely homemade, which is nice. Good cream cheeses and quick delivery.

Written by Theresa H. on 11/16/2009 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2007
Theresa ordered from here over a year ago

The lox & bagel sandwich was delic, but they forgot to pur mayo/mustard on my meat sandwich. Will definetally make this place my lox & bagel home.

Written by Michael Z. on 6/26/2007 | 1 other review | Member since 2007
Michael ordered from here over a year ago

high minimum for delivery and very slow service.

Written by Will C. on 2/27/2012 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2010
Will ordered from here over a year ago

Very uneven. Smoked salmon always good. Sturgeon ranges from excellent to very dry. I ordered a nova platter for $16. They delivered a nova sandwich ($9 on the menu). I called; they explained that the sandwich and the platter are essentially the same. I asked about the price difference; the gentleman sent the platter. To their credit, they're always polite and accomodating when I have to call. Unfortunately, I occasionally have to call...

Written by Gary J. on 3/30/2011 | 1 other review | Member since 2008
Gary ordered from here within the last week

everything is excellent! timely delivery as well!

Written by Katherine H. on 12/21/2009 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2008
Katherine ordered from here within the last year

great food - horrible delivery

Written by BETHANY A. on 10/27/2008 | Member since 2008
BETHANY ordered from here over a year ago