Portofino Pasta & Pizza

Ordered a pizza with Prociutto - got a pizza with ham, ordered sparkling water got still. While the pizza was still pretty good it would be nice if they'd get the order correct or at least call me and let me know they were sending me something other than what I ordered....(when I say ham, I'm aware of what prociutto is - I mean this was oscar mayer lunch meat style not thinly sliced aged and cured ham....)

Written by Chiharu D. on 1/16/2012 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2008
Chiharu ordered from here over a year ago

Ordered a pizza online, they messed up my order, the dough was thick and smelled raw, the ham (which i didn't order) smelled horrible. I called to get another one but the guy told me they're too busy. So rude. Will never EVER make the mistake of ordering from that place again

Written by Perla C. on 12/15/2011 | 1 other review | Member since 2011
Perla ordered from here over a year ago

12 hours after eating a Lamb Gyro from Portofino I had a severe case of food poisoning. Although it is impossible to conclusively prove it was this that caused the sickness, this was the only thing I ate differently from my wife for 48 hours and she was fine......

Written by Mark H. on 12/5/2011 | Member since 2010
Mark ordered from here over a year ago

HORRIBLE - THE CHICKEN SOUP WAS RANCID AND THE PASTA PORTION SMALL.

Written by Kelly P. on 11/22/2011 | Member since 2010
Kelly ordered from here over a year ago

Food good, but delivery guy makes a mess of everything - food arrives spilled out of the containers. I don't get that. Last order from Portofino tonight.

Written by Edward L. on 10/10/2011 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2006
Edward ordered from here over a year ago

Pasta was OK, no real flavor in the vodka or alfredo sauce. Salad was inedible because it was wilted from being in a container sitting on top of hot pasta. Dressing on the side must be a foreign concept as the salad was covered in dressing. Side of meatballs were tasty as were the mozzarella sticks. Overall pobably would not order again, food is mediocre at best, they can't follow simple instructions and delivery time exceeded the estimate. Better options in the area.

Written by TIM L. on 3/7/2011 | 17 other reviews | Member since 2009
TIM ordered from here over a year ago

Worst Pizza I've ever had delivered. Ate 1 Slice and tossed the rest

Written by John C. on 5/17/2010 | Member since 2006
John ordered from here over a year ago

Love the pizza at this place, crust, selections everything is great. The staff are very friendly whether you eat in or have it delivered. My favorite pizza place on the UES!!

Written by Paul G. on 5/17/2010 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2008
Paul ordered from here within the last month

This is the final time I wil be ordering from Portofino. Over the last 6 months the times of have received deliveries the food has been on a serious decline from the pizza coming totally raw to the pasta being virtually cheeseless. Last night was the clincher. Barely any cheese on the pizza and crumby canned sauce and barely any cheese on the typically awesome garlic bread. So long Portofino!

Written by Jo Anne B. on 6/8/2009 | 18 other reviews | Member since 2008
Jo Anne ordered from here over a year ago

Quite possibly the worst pizza I have ever had. It was soggy, bland, and cold.

Written by Lauren S. on 3/13/2009 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2008
Lauren ordered from here over a year ago

Good pizza. Dough was not soggy and slices did not require a fork to eat as is often the case with some pizzas. Order was delivered accurately and promptly. Great value for the money. Would definitely recommend the pizza!

Written by Seth G. on 2/16/2009 | 1 other review | Member since 2009
Seth ordered from here over a year ago

Very cleanly made with perfect sized crust and thin crispy chewy bread w/ excellent non-greasy cheese. One of the most consistent pizza restaurants. (consistently better quality than ray bari's, ultimate pizza, and best pizza on 1st) Very fast delivery times.

Written by Foodie R. on 2/2/2009 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2008
Foodie ordered from here over a year ago

Pizza was perfectly cooked nice and crispy arrived pretty quickly i think i found a new delivery place in the UES......... and its cheap to boot.

Written by Stephen T. on 10/15/2008 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2007
Stephen ordered from here over a year ago

Good food and portions, especially the pastas and sandwiches. Decent pizza as well, but they refuse to use peg stands for some reason so more than likely you will be scraping your cheese off the box.

Written by Andrew C. on 7/28/2008 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2007
Andrew ordered from here over a year ago

outstanding food, great pizza and friendly staff

Written by Ami S. on 7/9/2007 | Member since 2007
Ami ordered from here within the last year