Sal's Pizzeria

Undercooked pizza presented in a partially collapsed box by a rude delivery guy.

Written by Trenton B. on 2/21/2013 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2013
Trenton ordered from here within the last year

Pizza is bigger than the box it comes in but thats a good thing. My boyfriend and I enjoy this REAL NY Pizza. I think we ordered two large pies and finished it between the four of us in two days. YUM

Written by susan s. on 11/30/2012 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2010
susan ordered from here within the last month

It's decent pizza. They're nice when you go there too so it's good to support a local business.

Written by Kylie J. on 10/24/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2012
Kylie ordered from here within the last year

Written by Nicholas M. on 7/13/2012 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2010
Nicholas ordered from here within the last year

Pretty disappointing. I just received an undercooked pizza that was shoved into a pizza box that was way too small for it. I'm not picky about pizza, but this was just plain gross. A total waste. Oh, yeah. Not that I wanted a soda, but I just realized that's a total lie... adding insult to injury.

Written by Sarah S. on 7/10/2012 | Member since 2009
Sarah ordered from here within the last year

always good and filling good, prompt and courteous delivery guy too

Written by Jose S. on 2/13/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2012
Jose ordered from here over a year ago

This is the crappiest pizza. Also, it was sliced by the most special person in the world, who sliced squares into the circle pizza.

Written by John L. on 1/13/2012 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2010
John ordered from here over a year ago

caeser salad was just lettuce and came with italian dressing not caeser dressing. The delivery guy called to tell me he couldnt find my address. when he finally got here the pizza was not in a bag to keep it warm and was so cold it was hard.

Written by Kate B. on 1/6/2012 | Member since 2010
Kate ordered from here over a year ago

Having just flown in to LGA late on a Sunday evening, we were craving pizza. Our usual delivery place (Roebling Pizza) was closed so we checked out the reviews and decided to give here a try. We ordered the pepperoni pizza with onions online. I called to ask if they could add extra fresh garlic and was told that they could. An hour later, we were home, unpacked and starving. I called to check on the whereabouts of our pizza - I was assured it would be with us in the next few minutes. Ten minutes later it arrived, without pepperoni and fresh garlic and topped with onions that looked like they were cut a week earlier and in a hurry. These were not the caramelized onions you would see on a Fornino pizza or even the tidy, thin, uniform strips you find on a fast food pizza; these were chunky, irregular cut pieces that look like something you would use for a soup you would later blend. When we tried to easy the pizza, all the toppings fell off in a sloppy pile leaving us to spoon them back on to try to eat them. We both ate a slice each and threw the other 6 away. This is the first time we haven't saved leftovers, maybe ever! I hope our experience was an anomaly but felt I had to write a review before someone fell into the same Sunday night trap.

Written by Vienna N. on 5/31/2011 | Member since 2007
Vienna ordered from here over a year ago

Love them!!

Written by Delores S. on 5/23/2011 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2011
Delores ordered from here within the last week

Pretty good. Very liberal with the toppings, which was nice, but the 4 stars it had when we ordered were very misleading. Tastes just like all the other pizza joints and was delivered cold.

Written by Jennifer S. on 4/5/2011 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2006
Jennifer ordered from here over a year ago

Oh man. Who cares how good the pizza is if they make you wait over an hour to get it. Too annoyed by them to enjoy it.

Written by Maya J. on 4/5/2011 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2010
Maya ordered from here over a year ago

ordered pasta and a sicilian pie they forgot the pizza but were very apologetic and very quickly brought me a delicious pizza i will be ordering from here again!

Written by lowell o. on 4/1/2011 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2011
lowell ordered from here within the last year

Pizza (Sicilian) is tasty but not amazing. It was also cold on arrival.

Written by Michael C. on 3/23/2011 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2008
Michael ordered from here over a year ago

One of the best slices in the area

Written by Noah M. on 2/14/2011 | 1 other review | Member since 2009
Noah ordered from here over a year ago