The Ultimate in Pizza Inc.

I'm not one to throw out food, but this pizza was awful. The crust was overcooked, and it had absolutely no flavor. Would not order again.

Written by Isabel A. on 4/6/2013 | 22 other reviews | Member since 2008
Isabel ordered from here within the last year

Delicious NY pizza! Best in the neighborhood.

Written by Tiffany K. on 4/4/2013 | 7 other reviews | Member since 2011
Tiffany ordered from here within the last week

Our kids LOVE this pizza. It is probably the best pizza in the neighborhood. And delivery is always speedy.

Written by Lorna M. on 3/9/2013 | Member since 2010
Lorna ordered from here within the last month

Usually I order regular pizza which is the best in the neighborhood - 5 star. Tonight I tried the "Ultimate" pizza. Never again. The crust was so soggy I couldn't hold the slice. Contrary to the menu descirption, there was no sauce. There were whole plum tomatoes - likely canned - plopped on the crust. No one bothered to squeeze out the liquid from the can which is probably why the crust was soaked. Soooo disappointed.

Written by Doris L. on 7/20/2012 | Member since 2008
Doris ordered from here within the last year

pizza was soggy and pizza was pushed to all one side. One side had all toppings and other had none...switching to Abitinos...much better!!!...this place just lost our business

Written by Matthew R. on 4/5/2012 | 9 other reviews | Member since 2012
Matthew ordered from here over a year ago

Love the Pizza Pazza (Individual Pizza), thin and delicious

Written by Leighann S. on 10/10/2011 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2009
Leighann ordered from here over a year ago

the pizza is ok, but the food is really poor quality and if something goes wrong with your order, they refuse to help. I ordered a panini sandwich along with 2 slices of pizza... they called me 45 minutes later only to tell me that they no longer make sandwiches. I asked why it took 45 minutes to call and they said sorry, they were busy. Then when I asked for a substitution, they said they cant help me out.... then i asked that my order be canceled all together and they said, sorry, I would have to call seamless web and cancel it... they were done. NEVER GIVING THEM BUSINESS EVER AGAIN.

Written by April H. on 8/15/2011 | Member since 2010
April ordered from here within the last year

Good thinner crust pizza. Consistent.

Written by Beth W. on 4/5/2011 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2009
Beth ordered from here over a year ago

Soggy pizza, doughy crust, cheese texture was bad

Written by Walter P. on 7/27/2010 | Member since 2010
Walter ordered from here over a year ago

We have been ordering from Ultimate Pizza for years--even when they were in their tiny sub-basement location. They may have changed chefs from time to time but it is consistently a neighborhood favorite. Fresh, good variety of pizza toppings and the eggplant parm dinner is a real winner in this household.

Written by thomas s. on 6/30/2010 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
thomas ordered from here within the last year

I ordered garlic bread, mussels and a slice of pizza. I got the slice of pizza because I was not expecting the mussels to be that good. Unfortunately the garlic bread, pizza and mussels were all terrible. The delivery came pretty quick but I would stick to the Chicken parm from Ultimate Pasta because these three items were awful (this is the first negative review I have ever written)

Written by Danielle B. on 2/16/2010 | 1 other review | Member since 2009
Danielle ordered from here over a year ago

best pizza in the hood, and one of the best in the city.

Written by Michael F. on 11/24/2009 | Member since 2009
Michael ordered from here within the last month

The pizza was undercooked, and the garlic knots I ordered were not delivered. So many other pizza places nearby are better than this place.

Written by Jennifer G. on 9/28/2009 | Member since 2007
Jennifer ordered from here over a year ago

best pizza in nyc!!!

Written by Lindsey S. on 12/31/2008 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2008
Lindsey ordered from here over a year ago

Food is good but the delivery service is VERY lacking. They often forget things and you have to wait an additional amount of time for redelivery and by that time you get it the original food is not as hot. Very frustrating!!!

Written by Reem j. on 8/31/2010 | 18 other reviews | Member since 2009
Reem ordered from here within the last year