Villa Mia Pizza

I would give them ZERO STARS if I could. I saw a few reviews on here saying that they take a long time--40 minutes one said. No big deal, I thought. Except it took an hour and 40 minutes, yes 100 minutes, for it to get here. And when it did, the pizza was OK, but it was not the pizza I ordered. Did I mention when I called to check where the pizza was, the guy who answered was indecipherable and interrupted me?

Written by Brian D. on 4/8/2013 | Member since 2012
Brian ordered from here within the last year

We had the fortunata pizza as recommended, and an eggplant parm hero. The pizza was all right - thick crust, kind of watery toppings. The hero was also all right - not the greatest bread, and the balance of eggplant, sauce and cheese was off. HOWEVER, the delivery person was fast and friendly, and the food came nice and hot.

Written by S D. on 3/23/2013 | 9 other reviews | Member since 2009
S ordered from here within the last year

This place has great authentic Italian pizza, I've lived in parkslope for 4 years and Villa Milla has never failed me. If you don't know what you want, they have great suggestions for you! If you want healthy order a margarita pizza or a salad Lol. Besides the pizza the pasta entrees are exceptionally good as well as the heros. What also makes this place so good is that it's family owned, run by two brothers who's end of day goal is not only good service, but delivering great food.

Written by Rodney H. on 2/7/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
Rodney ordered from here within the last year

great pizza for the price and the owner is super friendly

Written by Kenneth H. on 1/13/2013 | Member since 2011
Kenneth ordered from here within the last year

I'm sitting here munching on a slice of Villa Mia's sausage and red pepper pizza while I write this. The pizza is really good. The salad's good too. Seamless wasn't working this evening when I tried to order, so I phoned Villa Mia directly. No problem. They were perfectly amiable. The pizza arrived in good time. Everything was delivered just as we'd ordered it. Did I mention that this is a really good piece of pizza I'm eating? Nice bright well-seasoned tomato sauce. Good crust, chewy but not too hard. High-quality sausage and peppers and cheese. I could eat another one of these any night. I don't know about the rest of their menu, but tonight, their New York-style pizza is great.

Written by Patrick N. on 6/17/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2011
Patrick ordered from here over a year ago

Just ordered from this place and I must say their pizza is terrible and service even worse. I ordered a plain pizza and got it late and with spicy sauce. My kids couldn't even eat it so I had to make dinner. Called the restaurant and they suggested I call Seamless for a refund which I did. Well, they went ahead and called Seamless and said they weren't going to give a refund. All over bad experience. You should definitely avoid this place.

Written by sameer d. on 5/3/2012 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2009
sameer ordered from here over a year ago

Disappointing. Hardly any sauce on the pizza, half of the garlic knots didn't have a spec of garlic on them, and when I ordered a veggie pizza with no cheese on half, they sent us a very cheesy pizza with no veggies on half. And the spinach on the veggie pizza was frozen not fresh. Lame. So our dairy free vegetarians had nothing to eat, but dry bread knots. Never again.

Written by Racey N. on 5/2/2012 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2011
Racey ordered from here over a year ago

Followed the ordering advice of another reviewer and went with the Pizza Alla Fortunato. While it wasn't anything crazy-fancy or anything, it was really good -- which is enough for me! The cheese they use is really tasty, crust was a little sweet -- almost pretzely. I also ordered the Caesar Salad -- def ask for the dressing on the side (packaging was a touch messy). There was a nice amount of black pepper in the dressing. I'm sure I'll order from them again!

Written by Stephanie K. on 4/28/2012 | 17 other reviews | Member since 2010
Stephanie ordered from here over a year ago

The pizza is great! I love the Pizza Alla Fortunato. It has lots of veggies on it but it tastes much better than your typical veggie pizza. Also, I'm guilty of ordering spaghetti, the easiest thing to make at home, when I'm hungover. The meat sauce here is much better than other places I've tried. Yum!

Written by Sandra B. on 2/1/2012 | 7 other reviews | Member since 2007
Sandra ordered from here within the last year

I just ordered and finished eating. Pizza was cold and had a taste similar to what I can imagine cardboard would be. They left off 4 of our toppings, but I was willing to let that slide. The Salad was horrific as well. Overall some of the worst Pizza I've had in BKLYN, and I am not very hard to please. My girlfriend hated it worse than I.

Written by George C. on 12/12/2011 | Member since 2010
George ordered from here over a year ago

The crust lacks flavor. The cheese comes off the slices in clumps, which some people like but I don't really. Also, the eggplant that I ordered as a topping was breaded and fried before put on the pizza and baked which made the eggplant soggy on the pizza. It was cheap and fast, had good customer service, but wasn't impressive. I did like the tomato sauce, though.

Written by Nichole L. on 11/22/2011 | 19 other reviews | Member since 2011
Nichole ordered from here over a year ago

Good value for what you get. Chicken parm hero is really good, chicken parm plate is light on the chicken but still a good value. pizza is reaaallllly good.

Written by Kim G. on 10/24/2011 | 9 other reviews | Member since 2010
Kim ordered from here over a year ago

The food itself was alright. But they put pepperoni on the pizza instead of peppers, and put the dressing on the salad even though "on the side" was checked. Oh, and it took a full hour to get here. With so many places that make decent pizza, I see no reason to order from here again.

Written by Charlotte P. on 9/6/2011 | 37 other reviews | Member since 2005
Charlotte ordered from here over a year ago

Delicious pizza but it took an hour and when I called to find out if there was any problem the man on the phone was rude.

Written by Andrea A. on 8/2/2011 | Member since 2011
Andrea ordered from here over a year ago

Great Pizza and super fast and nice delivery guy!!! I have ordered tons of pizza and subs from here and they are always delicious. Extra plus for their slices still tasting great when reheated the next day or even 3 days later.

Written by Rohan G. on 6/27/2011 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2010
Rohan ordered from here over a year ago