Brother's Pizza

I have to give them five stars for amazing food and service. I have never been disappointed with Brother Pizza. One time they forgot my soda and the guy went back to the restaurant and brought it back to me. Another time I ordered and they waited outside until I came home from work. Dedicated staff and excellent pizza, would definitely give it a try if you haven't before and the coupon deals can't be beat!

Written by Rebecca S. on 4/6/2013 | 9 other reviews | Member since 2011
Rebecca ordered from here within the last year

By far the best pizza I have found in Brooklyn so far. There are so many places to choose from but why go anywhere else? I am not a crust eater because I generally find pizza crust dry and often over cooked. well when I have Brother's Pizza. I each everything!

Written by Jennifer J. on 9/23/2012 | Member since 2009
Jennifer ordered from here within the last month

Garlic knots said they came with marinara sauce on the menu but it wasn't in the delivery bag. Got a large pepperoni pizza and some slices only had 1 pepperoni. WTF?!

Written by Justin M. on 4/12/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2010
Justin ordered from here within the last month

Lied about pizza size! Ordered a Grandma's pizza and only got a 16 x 5.33 pizza. That means I got 2/3 of a pizza. 8 instead of 12 slices. 2/3 of the box empty. 1/3 of my payment unfulfilled. What is up with that??? Said its supposed to feed 12 ppl. How do you feed 12 ppl with 8 slices? NEVER ordering again.

Written by Geoffrey S. on 1/12/2013 | 19 other reviews | Member since 2009
Geoffrey ordered from here within the last year

Can it really be that hard to find a good pizza in this part of Brooklyn? I'm on the search for my new go-to pizza place, and Brothers will not be it. The pizza was mediocre, not what I've come to expect from a good NYC slice. Ordered a large sausage pie - Too sweet sauce (obviously canned tomato paste based, not fresh), too chewy and doughy crust (I prefer thin and a little crispy) added up to disappointment. Good news is, delivery was prompt and the food was hot and freshly made - so if it's to your taste, this may be a good spot for you. I'll continue looking elsewhere.

Written by jessica f. on 12/31/2012 | Member since 2012
jessica ordered from here within the last year

Great 14 inch pizza. Small personal pizzas are too small and large are too big. This one was just right for a few people.

Written by Brittany S. on 2/27/2012 | Member since 2010
Brittany ordered from here over a year ago

I do not recommend getting garlic on a veggie pizza. They use canned garlic, and so much of it that I couldn't eat a whole slice... and I put garlic on EVERYTHING! I'm seriously disappointed to have wasted my money on this place, and i'll have to throw out the rest... it's not edible.

Written by kristin m. on 12/26/2011 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2011
kristin ordered from here over a year ago

there are two other pizza places closer than brother's, but i don't even bother with them. brothers has great pizza, amazing eggplant heroes, and delicious garlic knots. delivery is quick and hassle-free. LOVE.

Written by Sarah P. on 9/14/2011 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2010
Sarah ordered from here within the last week

This is our late night delivery savior in WInsdor Terrace, where everything is closed by 11:00pm! Pizza is decent and cheap and their chicken finger combo is a great deal!

Written by Carla R. on 4/5/2011 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2008
Carla ordered from here over a year ago

mediocre pizza and slow delivery. Chicken wings were good tho.

Written by Daniel P. on 4/5/2011 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2011
Daniel ordered from here over a year ago

Our favorite pizza place in the neighborhood

Written by Catherine B. on 2/28/2011 | 19 other reviews | Member since 2010
Catherine ordered from here within the last week

As with most people, I don't generally write a review unless something is bad. Actually, I never write reviews. In any case, Brother's has been amazing. Does your meal include cheese? Consider it smothered. Never a disappointing dish, always fast delivery. One of the best spots to choose from on this here Seamless Web.

Written by Michael Beach B. on 2/16/2011 | Member since 2010
Michael Beach ordered from here over a year ago

The quality of Brothers' food is great. It's the opposite of Domino's - no cardboard crust. It's not gourmet, but it's REALLY good.

Written by Victoria V. on 8/10/2010 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2010
Victoria ordered from here within the last year

Pizza was ice cold, toppings were canned and rubbery.

Written by julieanne s. on 2/9/2010 | 9 other reviews | Member since 2009
julieanne ordered from here over a year ago

Pizza was cold, toppings were either canned or frozen, crust was stale.

Written by Kyli W. on 11/30/2009 | 16 other reviews | Member since 2006
Kyli ordered from here over a year ago