We exist to make hungry people happy

We get people the food they want, when they want - wherever they are. It's simple...

[ close ]
Seamless customers

You place your order

Simply order whatever you or your coworkers are hungry for at Seamless.com or using the Seamless smartphone app.

Media devices connecting to restaurants through Seamless

We send it to the restaurant

We immediately beam your order to the restaurant and they send you a confirmation email with delivery or pickup time estimate.

Delivery guy with Seamless customer

Your food arrives...Yum!

When your food’s ready, the restaurant delivers it or you pick it up. All you have to do is sign for it and enjoy it!

Bummer! BLT Fish Shack (21 W 17TH STREET, NY 10011) is no longer active on Seamless.

But we still want to feed you! Check out other great restaurants on Seamless.

Order online from similar nearby restaurants:

A Salt & Battery »

Seafood, American

112 Greenwich Avenue

Bareburger (8th Ave) »

American, Burgers

153 8th Ave

Cafeteria »

Breakfast, American, Gluten Free

119 7th Avenue

Cherry Sushi »

Japanese, Sushi, American

355 W 16th Street

Dirty Bird To-Go »

Sandwiches and Wraps, American


Elmo (New York) »

Salads, Sandwiches and Wraps, Wings, American, Burgers

156 7th Ave

Fiddlesticks »

Wings, American, Burgers


Jeanne and Gaston (14th St) »

Salads, Sandwiches and Wraps, American

212 W 14th Street

Just Salad (140 8th ave) »

Salads, American

140 8th Avenue

Pounds & Ounces »

American, Burgers

160 8th Ave

BLT Fish Shack

  • SW User Rating 0 ratings 18 reviews

21 W 17th Street (17th St. between 5th Ave. & 6th Ave.), NY, NY 10011 | (212) 691-8888

BLT Fish Shack Reviews

User rating

The food is good but not worth the cost. The $12 wedge salad is about the size of a side salad...for $18 you get one crab cake...the $9 lobster bisque had 3 little pieces of lobster in it. Probably won't order from here again.

Written by on 9/11/2014 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2008
Anne ordered from here within the last year

User rating

NYC best lobster roll

Written by on 7/10/2014 | Member since 2014
Mary ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Red Lobster quality at 4 times the price.

Written by on 5/23/2014 | Member since 2012
Todd ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

I absolutely love the food, service, and presentation of delivery from BLT Fish Shack! I usually order the Cod, which comes with salad and your choice of rice pilaf or roasted potatoes. The portions are substantial and are always accompanied by this delicious garlic bread with melted cheddar cheese. I am an EXTREMELY picky eater, but I am consistently impressed with my BLT Fish Shack delivery. The food comes nicely compartmentalized with a separate container of salad, and the manner in which the food is presented makes one feel that the place is very clean and organized (which it is, as I've been there on more than one occasion). For those concerned with the quality of "delivery" fish, the food is excellent quality and tastes great. BLT Fish Shack is consistently good, and will always be a favorite!

Written by on 2/2/2014 | Member since 2012
Lindsay ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Excellent food, organic salmon is superb!

Written by on 1/6/2014 | Member since 2011
Michelle ordered from here within the last year

User rating

The tuna was overcooked and the skate was under cooked. Waste of good fish.

Written by on 10/22/2013 | 10 other reviews | Member since 2011
CHASE ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Usually i have good experiences here; tonight it's been terrible. Order taking forever, and restaurant is absolutely useless in terms of getting more information. delivery person went out and shut off phone so i get no update of information. absolutely horrible experience tonight

Written by on 10/3/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2008
Zachary ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

You know you're in trouble when the best thing about your order is the plastic cutlery. Portions are over priced and ridiculously small. $25 for a quarter/lb piece of salmon. Barely enough lettuce in the salad to cover the bottom of the take-out carton. Fish sandwich is a joke: doughy square of thick battered cod.

Written by on 9/6/2013 | 15 other reviews | Member since 2006
Matthew ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

BLT Fish Shack is one of the two or three best restaurants which I've found on Seamless. The food is great and I've never had a delivery problem, except a few times the food has been delivered earlier than I expected.

Written by on 8/1/2013 | 8 other reviews | Member since 2007
Harvey ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Consistently delicious, fast delivery, healthy. I usually get the sea bass or the cod. Both are great. Each meal comes with side salad of greens, baked potatoes, and garlic bread. Seems expensive, but great value. Highly recommended.

Written by on 4/4/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2010
TOMASZ ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Great quality and very tasty but small portions for the price. On the flip side, they sent me a cake to thank me for my order!

Written by on 10/8/2012 | Member since 2012
Jennifer ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Food is good, but not great, and it arrived cold. For that much money it should be great and hot. BAD VALUE.

Written by on 9/13/2012 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2012
Brad ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Reliably delicious fish, reasonably quick delivery. Two separate deliveries forgot one of the items, but not a big deal.

Written by on 5/14/2012 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2009
Aisha ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Overly fried everything... so dissapointed, Will never order from here again. over priced and over fried.

Written by on 1/30/2012 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2005
Jeffrey ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

I like certain dishes here but there are some basic staples that they just can't seem to get right. Either bland or too much salt, etc., but the good dishes are great! It's like a treasure hunt.

Written by on 1/18/2012 | 51 other reviews | Member since 2007
Gitanjali ordered from here over a year ago


Enter your address below to see restaurants that deliver to you.

- or -