We exist to make hungry people happy

We get people the food they want, when they want - wherever they are. It's simple...

[ close ]
Seamless customers

You place your order

Simply order whatever you or your coworkers are hungry for at Seamless.com or using the Seamless smartphone app.

Media devices connecting to restaurants through Seamless

We send it to the restaurant

We immediately beam your order to the restaurant and they send you a confirmation email with delivery or pickup time estimate.

Delivery guy with Seamless customer

Your food arrives...Yum!

When your food’s ready, the restaurant delivers it or you pick it up. All you have to do is sign for it and enjoy it!

Bummer! Five Lamps Tavern (2756 Broadway, New York 10025) is no longer active on Seamless.

But we still want to feed you! Check out other great restaurants on Seamless.

Order online from similar nearby restaurants:

Bernheim Schwartz (Broadway) »

Sandwiches and Wraps, American

2911 Broadway

Bistro Ten 18 »

American, Brunch

1018 Amsterdam Ave

HENRY's (Broadway) »

American, Burgers

2745 Broadway

Lura Restaurant & Lounge »

American, Gluten Free

949 Columbus Ave

Mario's Gourmet »


934 Amsterdam Avenue

Metro Diner »

Diner, American

2641 Broadway

Ranch Deli (Columbus Ave) »

Salads, Deli, Sandwiches and Wraps, American

980 Columbus Avenue

The Manchester Diner »

Diner, Breakfast, American, Burgers

2800 Broadway

The West End (West End Ave) »

Pizza, American

955 West End Avenue

Toast »


2737 Broadway

Five Lamps Tavern

  • SW User Rating 0 ratings 14 reviews

2756 Broadway (Duke Ellington Blvd. & Broadway), New York, NY 10025 | (212) 663-0592

Five Lamps Tavern Reviews

User rating

Credit where credit's due: I read the previous reviews and took a knowing chance, since several months had passed since the last critique. I'm glad that I did. The order arrived within the promised window, my special instructions were followed perfectly, AND they packaged my nachos (universally a tough one to deliver well) with the meat separate...I hadn't thought to request that, and it made the order even better that way. Thanks!

Written by on 11/16/2014 | Member since 2012
Lisa ordered from here within the last year

User rating

ordered food, confirmed 15min later by restaurant (in itself a joke) but food never arrived. Restaurant phone doesn't work. At least Seamless gave me a full refund.

Written by on 9/20/2014 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2011
Dennis ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Good food and drinks, pleasant enough experience when you actually go there. But delivery, maybe not. After over an hour and my food still not here, I called the restaurant. There is something wrong with their phone, I had to call several times and ask them to switch phones so I could understand them, The woman on the phone explained that my order had been delivered to someone else, and asks if I would like them to make another for me. I say yes and ask for some extra fries. I am offered plain or chili, I say plain please (not everybody likes chili fries!) My order arrives very quickly after that and the food is hot and good. But they've sent me the chili fries. I'm sure they meant well, but I did request the other kind. Five Lamps, please repair your phone! From now on I'll stick to only eating in-restaurant.

Written by on 6/2/2014 | 1 other review | Member since 2012
Skylar ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Horrendous. Food was over an hour late, the staff didn't answer the phone for four calls (each five minutes apart), and when I finally did get through to someone they were beyond rude. They didn't even apologize for sending my food in 120 minutes and cold. DO NOT ORDER!!!!!!

Written by on 6/2/2014 | 3 other reviews | Member since 2011
Jayna ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Not indelible, but not delicious. I've ordered from here twice when literally nothing else was open. Fries are fine. Flatbreads are chewy but cheesy. Caesar salad is a joke. They just throw a head of romaine in a box and put some rank dressing on the side.

Written by on 4/1/2014 | 10 other reviews | Member since 2008
april ordered from here within the last year

User rating

The sliders were pretty decent. They still needed some mayo & grey poupon to flavor them more, but made to the temp I requested, so no problems with my order. I ordered the sinach dip, which tasted healthier than I expected, like frozen spinach with some cream, but it wasn't that creamy. I was personally hoping for something a little less healthy-tasting, but I'd probably order from them again.

Written by on 2/20/2014 | 16 other reviews | Member since 2012
Elizabeth ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Absolutely awful. I ordered 4 items. The restaurant called me back 4 separate times to tell me they were out of EACH item I ordered. How can you be out of flatbread pizza. Ridiculous. Do not order from this restaurant under any circumstance.

Written by on 1/20/2014 | Member since 2013
Lauryn ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Don't order from them! Order just arrived 30 mins late and ICE cold. I didn't want to eat it, I didn't want to wait for a new one, manager wouldn't refund my order. I'll never order from THEM again!

Written by on 1/11/2014 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2006
Thomas ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

They have so much potential but still not getting it. I tried the Tavern three times now. I've had their fish and chips, mac and cheese, and burger. Fish was soggy, mac and cheese was gritty and burger was so-so. Despite all this, my biggest complaint is their cheesecake. Charging $8 for a small plain cheesecake slice that was watery is outrageous. Not worth the prices they list.

Written by on 12/22/2013 | 5 other reviews | Member since 2013
Natalie ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Delivery took over 2 hours - and, when it finally arrived, the sauces from the food had dripped all the way through the bag, causing a huge mess in my apartment.

Written by on 12/16/2013 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2011
Eric ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Ordered on a Saturday night. Was supposed to be between 30-45 mins. Waited >2 hrs, after calling the restaurant 3 times (at the 75, 95, and 120 min mark). Food cold . Few apologies. Service is so bad, it's embarrassing.

Written by on 11/24/2013 | Member since 2011
Matthew ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

The Mac and cheese is kick ass! Wings are really good too! So good we ordered from here the next night too! On round two sandwiches were good too.

Written by on 11/22/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2012
Kelly ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Revising an original review. Delivery takes way too long. Food is good but they aren't staffed for timely delivery.

Written by on 11/19/2013 | 1 other review | Member since 2008
Elizabeth ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Burger was huge, fabulous, and cooked exactly as ordered!

Written by on 11/14/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2006
Beverly ordered from here within the last year


Enter your address below to see restaurants that deliver to you.

- or -