We exist to make hungry people happy

We get people the food they want, when they want - wherever they are. It's simple...

[ close ]
Seamless customers

You place your order

Simply order whatever you or your coworkers are hungry for at Seamless.com or using the Seamless smartphone app.

Media devices connecting to restaurants through Seamless

We send it to the restaurant

We immediately beam your order to the restaurant and they send you a confirmation email with delivery or pickup time estimate.

Delivery guy with Seamless customer

Your food arrives...Yum!

When your food’s ready, the restaurant delivers it or you pick it up. All you have to do is sign for it and enjoy it!

Bummer! Petaluma (1356 First Avenue, New York 10021) is no longer active on Seamless.

But we still want to feed you! Check out other great restaurants on Seamless.

Order online from similar nearby restaurants:

Delizia Ristorante »

Italian, Pizza, Late Night Dining

1374 1ST AVE.

Domino's Pizza - 1396 1st Ave »


1396 1st Avenue

Finestra Restaurant »

Italian, Pizza

1370 York Ave

Fratelli Brick Oven Pizzeria »

Italian, Salads, Pizza, Healthy

1317 1st Ave

La Crosta »

Italian, Pizza, Middle Eastern

436 E. 72ND STREET

Nino's Restaurant (1st Ave) »


1354 1st Avenue

Numero 28 UES »


1431 1st Avenue

Per Lei »



Petaluma Restaurant (1st Ave) »

Italian, Pizza

1356 1st Avenue

Session 73 »

Pizza, Sandwiches and Wraps, American

1359 1st Ave


  • SW User Rating 0 ratings 9 reviews

1356 First Avenue (E. 73 Street & 1st Ave.), New York, NY 10021 | (212) 772-8800

Petaluma Reviews

User rating

Food never arrived because they closed

Written by on 1/2/2014 | Member since 2012
Susan ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Yes, the pizza is small but delicious with interesting and delicate flavors. In my opinion among the best in the city.

Written by on 4/17/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2011
Wallace ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Have not ordered before. Delivery was quick but order was wrong. Dressing in salad not on side and wrong pizza delivered.

Written by on 4/4/2013 | Member since 2008
Margaret Ann ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Just got a delivery of food. not happy with it at all. its a shame they are usually pretty good.

Written by on 12/16/2012 | Member since 2008
Jennifer ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Pizza was delicious (authentic Italian) but arrived cold, and what they call large is significantly smaller than expected--just six little slices. Very expensive for what it was, considering size.

Written by on 5/15/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2008
Jessica ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Tiny, tiny pizza! Cold and tasteless! Will never order from here again :( :( Really disappointed.

Written by on 5/4/2012 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2011
Matthew ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

food arrived late and cold, don't order for delivery

Written by on 4/24/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2011
Brian ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

YUMMM! Petaluma pizza is delicious! Will def order again!! <3

Written by on 4/12/2012 | 18 other reviews | Member since 2011
Anastasia ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

My order arrived an hour and 20 minutes after it was placed, despite being quoted 30-45 minutes. My pizza was ice cold and was just handed to me in the box-no insulation to keep it warm. Too bad bc this restaurant has decent food when dining in but not worth the effort to order delivery. I won't be ordering from them again.

Written by on 2/2/2012 | Member since 2010
Joslyn ordered from here over a year ago


Enter your address below to see restaurants that deliver to you.

- or -