We exist to make hungry people happy

We get people the food they want, when they want - wherever they are. It's simple...

[ close ]
Seamless customers

You place your order

Simply order whatever you or your coworkers are hungry for at Seamless.com or using the Seamless smartphone app.

Media devices connecting to restaurants through Seamless

We send it to the restaurant

We immediately beam your order to the restaurant and they send you a confirmation email with delivery or pickup time estimate.

Delivery guy with Seamless customer

Your food arrives...Yum!

When your food’s ready, the restaurant delivers it or you pick it up. All you have to do is sign for it and enjoy it!

Bummer! Pizza Rustica (817 2nd Ave., NY 10017) is no longer active on Seamless.

But we still want to feed you! Check out other great restaurants on Seamless.

Order online from similar nearby restaurants:

Abitino's Pizza & Italian Kitchen (2nd Ave) »

Italian, Pizza, Wings

733 SECOND AVENUE

Cosi (3rd Ave) »

Salads, Pizza, Sandwiches and Wraps

685 3rd Ave.

Davio's Northern Italian Steakhouse (Lexington Ave) »

Italian, Steakhouse

447 Lexington Avenue

La Trattoria (2nd Avenue) »

Italian, Pizza

844 2ND AVENUE

Osteria Laguna »

Italian

209 EAST 42ND ST.

Padre Figlio (44th St) »

Italian

310 East 44th Street

Pastafina »

Italian, Pizza

712 3RD AVENUE

Patsy's Pizzeria (2nd Ave) »

Italian, Pizza

801 2nd Avenue

Pazzo Pizza »

Italian, Pizza

766 Second Avenue

Piccolo Fiore »

Italian

230 E 44th St


Pizza Rustica

  • SW User Rating 56 ratings 30 reviews

817 2nd Ave. (2nd Ave. & 44th St.), NY, NY 10017 | (212) 697-8848

Pizza Rustica Reviews

User rating

this is my go-to pizza place. great pizza for a great price!

Written by on 1/31/2014 | 1 other review | Member since 2013
Emily ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Excellent pizza. They do not skimp on ingredients, like some places where you barely get any cheese.

Written by on 12/9/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2013
Jason ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Said 30-45 minutes, food tracker said out for delivery 20 minutes later. 50 minutes later I call and she says he left. Which is fine. Then asks me if I ordered pizza or kitchen, after already asking my name. Puts me on hold again and the comes back to tell me he is leaving now...well if the pizza is great it may be worth it but who knows as the kids eating it will most likely be in bed when it arrives.

Written by on 12/4/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2006
Donna ordered from here within the last year

User rating

C sanitation grade!!! Not sure how they're still open

Written by on 11/5/2013 | Member since 2012
Tricia ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Got the veal scallopini marsala. Real good

Written by on 9/30/2013 | Member since 2012
Dominic ordered from here within the last year

User rating

I have never written a review before, but this was so atrocious that I actually felt like I'd be doing a misdeed by neglecting to write about it. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, the small. It came after about 50 minutes, which is fine. It was cold, which was less fine. When I opened the box, the pizza had folded over itself, cheese dangling, slices on top of slices. It looked as though the delivery guy had punted it a few times before knocking on my door. This, too, was less fine. The pizza itself tasted good, but I ordered pepperoni. There were probably 7. 7 pepperonis on the whole pizza. So, in sum, I received a cold, sloppy, cheese pizza with 7 pepperonis that had clearly been dropped at least once. This is New York. There's practically a pizza restaurant for every person, and more than anywhere else in the world is there a better chance of getting a decent slice at any one of them. It is not worth it ordering from this place, and I will not do it ever again.

Written by on 9/6/2013 | Member since 2009
Steven ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Used to be really good, but their delivery time has gotten really bad, as they now handle both Seamless and GrubHub orders. What used to be in my hands in 30 minutes, now takes 80. . .

Written by on 7/23/2013 | 12 other reviews | Member since 2008
Thomas ordered from here within the last year

User rating

Delivery was slow - took an hour

Written by on 6/25/2013 | 18 other reviews | Member since 2013
Jeri ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Food arrived in 15 minutes, which is normally a good thing... However not when the calzone is cold in the middle and the chicken wings are not cooked through. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know that wings are not done when the skin is still rubbery and not crisp.... Funny part is I asked for the wings "extra crispy" on my order. Clearly they rushed the order to send it with another delivery... Maybe they should think twice about doing that before they give someone salmonella!

Written by on 5/1/2013 | 22 other reviews | Member since 2009
TIM ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Worst restaurant ever

Written by on 4/13/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2011
Trevor ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

It's been over an hour and I still haven't received my order. Plus, I called the restaurant, and the woman who picked up the phone was incredibly rude. Don't even care what the food tastes like at this point.

Written by on 11/12/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2010
Rebecca ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

the pizza does not taste good - my child who loves pizza would not eat it and neither would i

Written by on 11/9/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2010
Amelia ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

I love Pizza Rustica. Their delivery is ALWAYS super quick (I do live in the relative neighborhood though) and the food is always, ALWAYS good. It's so inexpensive for New York City and I've never had a bad meal there. Their Eggplant pizza is my favorite slice in New York and their Shrimp Parm entree is beyond killer. I love this place.

Written by on 9/15/2012 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2012
Chris ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

Very slow on delivery hour and a half and still not here....been on its way for over 35 min

Written by on 6/29/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2009
andrew ordered from here over a year ago

User rating

terrible - slop - the pastas were horrible, the sandwiches were dry - the mozz sticks were even awful!

Written by on 5/18/2012 | 6 other reviews | Member since 2010
Dan ordered from here over a year ago

FIND SIMILAR RESTAURANTS

Enter your address below to see restaurants that deliver to you.

- or -