Pauline and Sharon's Pizza

Don't listen to the haters, the pizza is on point. Amongst my favorite in all the boroughs.

Written by Arthur S. on 4/22/2013 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2009
Arthur ordered from here over a year ago

The wings were gross and my food was cold when it got here, despite my only living two blocks away. Pizza was okay.

Written by Caitlin G. on 2/2/2013 | Member since 2013
Caitlin ordered from here within the last year

Excellent pizza! As others mentioned, this is not standard NY style pizza. It's closer to brick oven / gourmet. Perfect crust. Sauce has a bit of a kick to it. By far my favorite pie in Brooklyn! They offer a 14" which is just the right size for us and rare in NY delivery. Fresh basil on every pie I've ordered (usually a red pie with pepperoni and green peppers) makes for a nice touch. I have ordered from this place over twenty times and have yet to be anything but impressed. Friendly delivery fella. Always arrives hot even though I'm quite a few blocks away, and uphill. They only offer sodas that use real sugar, no HF corn syrup. If you order a coke it comes in a bottle imported from Mexico. Love it.

Written by William S. on 2/1/2013 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2012
William ordered from here within the last month

100% great gourmet pizza. This is the real deal and not your average slice. Very yummy, including those wings!

Written by Brittany W. on 1/4/2013 | 21 other reviews | Member since 2010
Brittany ordered from here within the last year

Really bad. Another Seamless restaurant where I just don't get why the reviews are so stellar. Ordered veggie pizza which came not at all as described. And it had semi-raw french fries on top?! So gross. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza. Just as bad if not worse. The cheese is rubbery and tasteless, too much of it. Bland sauce. And pretty bad dough which is usually the one thing you can count on with NY style pizza.

Written by Nicole B. on 10/9/2012 | 4 other reviews | Member since 2012
Nicole ordered from here within the last year

Hmmm. The food came in the 30-45 min window and was correct. The salad was great, fresh, bigger than expected with a nice bunch of veggies and greens. It came with feta, which it doesn't mention, but I like feta so that's fine. The taco was ehh. It was ok. Not great but ok. The wings were awful. They were soggy and over breaded and just plain bad.

Written by moria h. on 8/23/2012 | 19 other reviews | Member since 2011
moria ordered from here within the last year

Their pizza is awesome! Their chicken wings are terrible though, but the blue cheese they come with is awesome! I dipped my pizza in it.

Written by Ben S. on 5/18/2012 | Member since 2012
Ben ordered from here within the last year

Terrible. I'll never order from here again. Avoid the "buffalo chicken wings" at all cost.

Written by Craig M. on 5/16/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2011
Craig ordered from here within the last year

Definitely the best pizza I've had in Park Slope (and even beyond). I've been to Grimaldi's, Lucali's, etc. At P&S, you get an awesome pie with more flavor and at a much more reasonable price. I've had the tacos and fries as well. Tasty eats.

Written by Jessica L. on 2/13/2012 | 1 other review | Member since 2007
Jessica ordered from here within the last year

Do not order chicken wings from anywhere else! I don't know what they put in that blue cheese dip, but it's like crack! Also a good place to get tacos, the authentic kind with that artisanal twist, but for the same price as the bodegas.

Written by Virginia L. on 12/12/2011 | 2 other reviews | Member since 2011
Virginia ordered from here within the last month